15a Lesson - More Secondary Dominant Functions

Secondary dominant functions for chords other than V

At the end of the Unit 14a, you completed the process of transforming a ii⁷ chord into V⁷/V. In the final instructions, I suggested that you try altering chords other than the ii chord to see if you could create secondary dominants for chords other than V.

Let’s work through this in the following example. Harmonize the progression in four-part harmony; then alter chords to create secondary dominant chords. How many options are possible if you only alter existing chords? Assuming that you created a secondary dominant chord, try changing it into secondary leading-tone chord.

Conclusions

The previous example has multiple chords that are connected by root movement of a descending P5, which is the reason that it provides multiple opportunities for secondary dominant chords. In the example below, the secondary chords are placed next to their closely related diatonic counterparts so that you can see not only how similar the pitches are but also how they share voice-leading and function. This includes a secondary dominant chord that we had not looked at yet: V⁷/ii. You will notice that this chord is as closely related to the vi⁷ chord as the V⁷/V was related to the ii⁷ chord.

Tonicizing chords other than V

In music, secondary dominant functions can appear anywhere the composer would like to emphasize a chord or prolong its function. Any major, minor, or dominant quality can be tonicized.

For secondary leading-tone chords:

• For minor chords, you may use a V, a V⁷, a vii^o, or a vii^o7. You should avoid using vii^ø7 (half-diminshed seventh chord) because the chordal seventh will resolve more “weakly” than the standard fully diminished seventh chord.
• For major and dominant chords, you may use a V, a V⁷, a vii^o, vii^ø7, or a vii^o7. Notice that you may use either a fully diminished or half-diminished seventh chord, even though the naturally-ocurring seventh chord built off the 7th scale degree in a major key will always be a half-diminished chord. For tonicizing a major chord, fully diminished chords actually appear more often than half-diminished chords, because they further strengthen the voice-leading.

Altering root movement

The following example uses a IV chord instead of a ii chord, and this changes the root movement for much of the passage. Try adding secondary dominant or leading-tone chords in the spots marked with an “x”. The note in the bass is only there as a placeholder, so please feel free to change it. You should experiment with various inversions to see if you can create more melodic bass lines as well.

Which chords created the smoothest voice-leading? Were you able to create a harmonization that has good voice-leading while also sounding convincing?

Conclusions

The most straightforward option is to use root-position secondary dominant functions in each spot creating a progression that would look something like this:

The voice-leading follows the standard resolutions for the tendency tones in each secondary dominant chord. In this progression, you must alternate between complete and incomplete chords to avoid objectional parallels.

Secondary functions used to create a smooth bass line

There are countless other options you could use to embellish this progression though. You probably noticed the disjunct bass line in the root-position harmonization example, but the three upper voices had smooth voice-leading. By using inversions of secondary dominant chords and/or secondary leading-tone chords, you can create more melodic bass lines. Take your previous harmonization (or use the clean version below), and alter it by inserting secondary dominant functions at each spot marked with an x. You should be able to create an entirely stepwise bass line. Remember that if you need to change the openness of a chord’s voicing, it can be helpful to have one voice jump a fourth by moving from the third of the first chord to the third of the second chord in an inner voice.

Are there multiple options for any of the chords? Where does the soprano force difficult decisions and resolutions?

Conclusions

Here is one option for a smoother, more melodic bass line.

You probably notice when listening to this how similar this sounds to modern sources of harmonic progressions such as pop and jazz. A melodic bass line is often employed in these styles.